• All American Wrestling
  • AAW Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[40]
• Capital City Championship Combat
  • C*4 Championship (1 time)[41]
  • C*4 Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Mike Bailey[42]
• Combat Revolution Wrestling
  • CRW Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Pat Skillz[43]
• Combat Zone Wrestling
  • CZW Iron Man Championship (1 time)[44]
• Elite Wrestling Revolution
  • EWR Heavyweight Championship (2 times)[4]
  • Elite 8 Tournament (2005)
• International Wrestling Syndicate
  • IWS Canadian Championship (1 time)[41]
  • IWS World Heavyweight Championship (3 times)[4][45]
• North Shore Pro Wrestling
  • NSPW Championship (1 time)[41]
• Pro Wrestling Guerrilla
  • PWG World Championship (3 times)[46][47][48]
  • PWG World Tag Team Championship (3 times) – with El Generico (2) and Super Dragon (1)[49][50][51]
• Pro Wrestling Illustrated
  • Ranked #6 of the top 500 singles wrestlers in the PWI 500 in 2016[52][53]
• Ring of Honor
  • ROH World Championship (1 time)[54]
  • ROH World Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with El Generico[55]
• Rolling Stone
  • Best Heel (2015)[56]
  • Best Promos (2015)[57] Tied with John Cena
  • Best Storyline (2015)[56] vs. John Cena
  • Rookie of the Year (2015)[56]
  • WWE Match of the Year (2015)[56] vs. John Cena at Money in the Bank
• SoCal Uncensored
  • Match of the Year (2011) with Super Dragon vs. The Young Bucks on December 10[58]
  • Wrestler of the Year (2005, 2011, 2012)[58][59][60]
• Squared Circle Wrestling
  • 2CW Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[61]
  • 2CW Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Jason Axe
• Wrestling Observer Newsletter
  • Best Brawler (2010–2012)[62][63][64]
  • Feud of the Year (2010) vs. El Generico[62]
• WWE
  • WWE Universal Championship (1 lần)
  • WWE Intercontinental Championship (2 lần)
  • WWE United States Championship (1 lần,hiện tại)
• WWE NXT
  • NXT Championship (1 time)

Lucha de Apuesta record